Cheap Car Rentals in George Town, the Cayman Islands

George Town, Cayman Islands

5 Feb — 12 Feb

Same drop-off

Sun 5/2

Noon

Sun 12/2

Noon

Driver's age:

26-65Other

What is the cheapest time to rent a car in George Town, Cayman Islands?

January

1,313,937 ₫

February

961,989 ₫

March

1,149,694 ₫

April

1,055,842 ₫

May

938,526 ₫

June

844,673 ₫

July

938,526 ₫

August

844,673 ₫

September

727,358 ₫

October

821,210 ₫

November

1,079,305 ₫

December

2,017,832 ₫

Currently, the cheapest month to rent a car in George Town, Cayman Islands is September. The most expensive time to rent a car is December. The cheapest prices for each month are shown above, but prices will vary based on availability, how far out you book your rental car, and of course, car type.

Top rental agencies in George Town, the Cayman Islands

All major car rental suppliers in George Town, the Cayman Islands

Budget

5.3

Fair

43 reviews•1 location

Check prices

Overview

Recent reviews

2.4

Poor|Mar 2018

Car not clean, old, tires worn, front fender held on by screws had to push back in place after hitting bumps. Was extended here due to storm in the North East US. They wanted to charge an additional $125/day. Close to the cost of one week rental. I asked if I could return and re-rent fo 2 days at dado rate they for 256 I could. Returned and rented fro ANDY’S for daily rate of 39$

4.8

Mediocre|Mar 2018

The car had minor damage to the front end. The car was dirty. Expensive for what we got. Also price ended up being substantially more than quoted price.

3.6

Poor|May 2017

When fan belt failed, they brought me a replacement within 3 hours. (Although Spare tire in replacement had zero pressure!). Quick drop off Saturday morning.

Waited over one hour to get car (long line/slow process).Both cars old (43K and 50K+miles).Had to press Brake pedal almost to floor to stop on first car. Steering wheels on right side.

10.0

Wonderful|Apr 2017

Agent was helpful, friendly and upgraded us to a Ford Explorer which worked well for four adults with luggage and groceries. No complaints.

10.0

Wonderful|Apr 2017

The office was pretty much deserted when I picked up and dropped off, so I had their full attention. That said, very polite and pleasant, a near-new minivan that was very comfortable for four adults plus gear. I would definitely recommend.

10.0

Wonderful|Apr 2017

Fast service, easy pick up from airport.

Not very good signs for dropping car off back at airport. Need better signs for airport rental car return. Didn't see any at all.

1 out of 15

Avis

8.6

Very good

9 reviews•1 location

Check prices

Overview

Recent reviews

10.0

Wonderful|Dec 2022

It was quick and efficient to get our car from Grand Cayman Airport Avis. The last day our car didn't start, we tried to get it jumped but car wouldn't start. Called Grand Cayman Airport AVIS and they had someone there in less than 10 minutes to help us make our flight. Super wonderful and helpful in a stressful situation. Thanks to the nice people at Grand Cayman Airport Avis!!

4.0

Mediocre|Jul 2022

Car was fine. I did not like the additional gas charge after I filled up the car.

10.0

Wonderful|Apr 2022

Friendly staff!

8.8

Very good|Mar 2020

Staff was friendly, car was very clean and location was super convenient.

Price was high when we included insurance- with more US insurance was applicable and/or coverage was lower.

9.2

Wonderful|Jan 2020

All went very well

Too expensive

9.2

Wonderful|Mar 2018

I liked the people (except one!), the efficiency, the car itself, the location.

I did not like that when I left my jacket in the car, my email about it was not answered, and when I went back to ask about it, they looked in the back room and said it was not there, and I must have left it somewhere else. I did not. It wasn't a great jacket, but things got pretty chilly when I returned to winter in the US without it.

1 out of 3

Hertz

8.2

Very good

18 reviews•4 locations

Check prices

Overview

Recent reviews

2.0

Poor|Nov 2022

We booked a compact and they gave us an economy without compensation. A blonde female employee remarked our luggage was not going to fit in the economy car and tried to upsell us to a van. Of course, it would have fit in the card we reserved months ahead of he trip. They didn’t have luggage carts at drop off and the blonde female employee didn’t help, just said it was too bad. There is no effort to help customers. They have no maps. It was an unpleasant interaction all around.

8.0

Very good|Nov 2022

Close to airport. Car with 67,000 miles, pretty beat up. Pressure to buy additional insurance. But very quick transactions getting and returning car.

6.0

Okay|Oct 2022

All the added expenses caused the price to be almost doubled. The rest was good.

10.0

Wonderful|Jun 2022

Very fast service, nice and friendly staff, reasonable prices. Thanks

10.0

Wonderful|May 2022

Excellent customer service at pick-up/drop off. Thank you.

4.0

Mediocre|Apr 2022

Car sizes are categorized different and are smaller than expected based on industry standard

1 out of 6

Thrifty

8.2

Very good

6 reviews•1 location

Check prices

Overview

Recent reviews

6.0

Okay|Dec 2019

Drop off fast

First car rented had 3 of 4 tires in very poor condition

8.0

Very good|Dec 2019

Drop off was easy.

Pickup staff was a little unfriendly and did not go over any instructions except to remind us to drive on the left side of the road.

5.6

Fair|Dec 2019

Drop off was good

No one was available at desk for pick up, even though it was during open hours. Had to take expensive taxi to hotel and spend most of next day awaiting for a car to be delivered. Very poor customer service upon arrival.

5.2

Fair|Mar 2017

Response to a problem with the car was very fast.

Rear view mirror on first car was so loose it would not stay adjusted. Replacement car had worn and mismatched tires, One tire was very low and needed inflation. Dashboard tire inflation warning stayed on for entire rental period causing repeated checks of tire psi. Wind shield wipers were old and ineffective on both cars.

10.0

Wonderful|Jan 2017

Prompt friendly service

10.0

Wonderful|Oct 2016

Quick service At great prices

1 out of 2

Dollar

8.0

Very good

1 review•1 location

Check prices

Overview

Payless

7.8

Good

6 reviews•1 location

Check prices

Overview

Recent reviews

5.2

Fair|Nov 2019

Car was fine. Drove well no issues.

Employee at the rental counter was borderline harassing with the rental experience. She was very rude, when performing the car inspection before leaving she was so insulting to me & my wife that my wife had to walk away. She repeatedly cut me off while I was speaking saying it was company policy to perform things a certain way. She was so smug and rude, then refused to provide her name & when I asked for her supervisor she gave me the phone number to her own desk. I’ve rented cars in over a dozen countries & I’ve never had anyone treat me that way. It really spoiled the beginning of our anniversary trip.

8.0

Very good|Apr 2018

Nice little car.

Long time to wait in line.

7.2

Good|Mar 2018

efficient check in & out. good gas milieage.

Be sure to check wuth your insurance company about liability coverage. I thought I was covered anywhere but I called and was told that I am only covered in US & Canada so I bought the liability. Your credit card will cover the collision.

9.6

Wonderful|Nov 2017

nice car, quick in, quick out

6.0

Okay|Nov 2017

Payless counter was clear I used. Sent to Avis to pick up car. Avis people were rude.

6.0

Okay|Jan 2017

Car was fine

You need to straighten out insurance. I thought I had bought insurance only to arrive at the counter and be told that my insurance was no good with Payless and I had to buy it from them. They claim to know nothing about what I had already bought. Is this some kind of scam.?

1 out of 2

Firefly

7.6

Good

3 reviews•1 location

Check prices

Overview

Recent reviews

6.0

Okay|Jan 2022

The car wasn’t in great shape, the brake pads are going and the windshield wipers were very old, but the AC works and it got us where we needed to go.

4.0

Mediocre|Jul 2017

Nice little car..friendly staff

You might want to give people a heads up before they get to the counter about: 1-$20 charge for international driving permit 2-Insurance that they really push is very expensive. Example...our $22 rental turned out to be $88 after all the BS! You know about these add ons....you should let folks know before they get there

6.4

Okay|Sep 2016

Employees courtesy

The car itself. It was a bitten car. It needs to retire that car urgently

1 out of 1

Alamo

7.5

Good

9 reviews•1 location

Check prices

Overview

Recent reviews

8.0

Very good|Aug 2019

The staff was great

Can't think of anything.

9.2

Wonderful|Jun 2019

A little faster check out and check in would be better

6.8

Okay|May 2019

Good price for rental. Nice staff.

Yes, it was a cheap rental. But the car was in very poor condition. Rental car had close to 50,000 miles and pre-existing damage all over, and had that nasty used car smell. I understand you get what you pay for, but when I booked an compact class still expected to have a little bit better quality.

5.6

Fair|May 2019

Staff Friendly and Helpful. Drop off easy.

During Pick the the branch did not have a copy of the insurance policy for review which I would have expected

7.6

Good|Apr 2018

Car was what we reserved and was clean and spacious.

Check out was ungodly long. Only two people available to process reservations when there were multiple flights arriving. Most people had to wait outside in the heat. Car pulled considerably to the left.

5.6

Fair|Apr 2018

Not enough help behind counter when picking up vehicle

1 out of 3

Car Rental FAQs

Which car rental company is considered to be the best in George Town, Cayman Islands?

Taking our users’ ratings and reviews into consideration, Avis (8.6 rating), Hertz (8.2 rating) and Thrifty (8.2 rating) seem to be the best rental car companies in George Town, Cayman Islands.

What are gas prices like in George Town, Cayman Islands?

The average gas price in George Town, Cayman Islands is 37,306 ₫/liter over the past month, costing you anywhere between 1,678,789 ₫ and 2,424,918 ₫ to fill up a car’s gas tank.

How much does it cost to rent a car in George Town, Cayman Islands for a week from Ace?

Ace is one of the most popular car rental companies in George Town, Cayman Islands, offering car rentals for around 11,189,817 ₫ per week on average.

How far in advance should I rent a car in George Town, Cayman Islands for the best price?

Booking your car rental early can save you up to 8% on your rental. Aim to book your car rental at least 55 days in advance to take advantage of a below average price in George Town, Cayman Islands.